Holes and Magic Treehouse Books

Similarities

 Differences

 

Cover does not indicate a children's book

 

Not a series

 

No pictures

 

Older audience?

 

Not educational

 

Main character grows

 

There are more characters

 

Unlike Jack and Annie, main characters not innocent--criminals?

 

Characters are lower class, not suburban

Women (Morgan, warden, lawyer) have power

 

About history

Different view of history--involves main character

Serious events

Main character centrally affected by them

 

There are villains

A typical kid as main character

No central female except villain

 

Adults are almost always enemies

 

Violence described more graphically

Helping others as theme?

No one helps him/ no one really helps anyone (except two main characters)

Good triumphs

 
 

More detail--more specific, more visual

 

Characters' thoughts expressed--more sense of interior life

Adventure away from home, then a return home

Contains more surprises--more than one story line, etc; unpredictable, complex

Problems all solved by end

Problems not always easy to solve

Fantasy world--everything connected, no loose ends

More complicated connections, etc.--less easily believable?

 

Or: it's more realistic

 

Focus on storytelling rather than on teaching

 

It's humorous

Main characters are underdogs who win

 
 

Race issues mentioned

 

Questions authority


classroom page / Pleasures page